Overcoming the 6 barriers to IT modernization

IT modernization is a necessity for organizations aiming to stay competitive. However, the journey toward modernization has significant hurdles. Understanding these barriers and implementing effective solutions is crucial for the journey. Here, we explore the key factors impeding IT modernization and provide recommendations to overcome them (with real-world illustrations of strategies).

Legacy systems and technical debt

• Barrier: Legacy systems, often deeply embedded in an organization’s operations, pose a significant challenge to IT modernization. These outdated systems are not only costly to maintain but also hinder the integration of new technologies, agility, and business value delivery.
• Solution: A phased approach to modernization can mitigate the risks associated with legacy systems. For instance, Capital One successfully transitioned from mainframe systems to a cloud-first strategy by gradually migrating critical applications to Amazon Web Services (AWS). It adopted a microservices architecture to decouple legacy components, allowing for incremental updates without disrupting the entire system. Additionally, leveraging cloud-based solutions reduced the burden of maintaining on-premises infrastructure.

Budget constraints

• Barrier: IT modernization requires substantial investment, and budget constraints are a common hurdle. Organizations often struggle to justify the upfront costs of modernization projects, especially when the ROI is not immediately apparent.
• Solution: To address budget constraints, organizations should adopt a strategic approach to funding IT modernization. For example, some clients explore alternative funding models such as opex through cloud services (rather than traditional capital expensing), which spread costs over time. Also communicating clearly how the debt impacts business strategy and goals in an executive-friendly fashion is key. When trying to rationalize investing, IT often makes the mistake of using language that doesn’t resonate with business peers, which makes it difficult to get consensus on funding.

Skill gaps and workforce resistance

• Barrier: The rapid evolution of technology has created a significant skills gap in the IT workforce. Many organizations lack the expertise required to implement and manage modern IT solutions. Furthermore, resistance to change among employees can impede modernization efforts.
• Solution: Invest in continuous learning and development programs to upskill the existing workforce. For instance, AT&T launched a comprehensive reskilling initiative called “Future Ready” to train employees in emerging technologies such as cloud computing, cybersecurity, and data analytics. The compay fostered a culture of innovation by involving employees in the modernization process and addressing their concerns. Change management strategies, including clear communication and incentives, helped overcome resistance and drive adoption.

Security and compliance concerns

• Barrier: Modernizing IT systems often involves handling sensitive data and integrating with external platforms, raising security and compliance concerns. Organizations fear that new technologies may introduce vulnerabilities and complicate regulatory compliance.
• Solution: Implement a robust security framework that includes regular risk assessments, threat modeling, and continuous monitoring. For example, a financial services firm adopted a zero trust security model to ensure that every access request is authenticated and authorized. It collaborated with compliance experts to ensure that modernization efforts adhered to industry regulations and standards and leveraged automated compliance tools to streamline the process and reduce the risk of human error.

Integration challenges

• Barrier: Integrating new technologies with existing systems is a complex task that can lead to compatibility issues and operational disruptions. The lack of standardized protocols and interfaces further complicates integration efforts.
• Solution: Embrace API-driven integration to facilitate seamless communication between disparate systems. For instance, an entertainment-driven technology organization used middleware solutions to bridge the gap between legacy and modern applications, enabling it to scale its services globally. Besides enabling scaling, the middleware also allowed the company to “pick off” the legacy services rather than forcing a riskier, big-bang approach to modernizing them. Finally, adopting a modular approach to system design enhanced flexibility and simplified future integrations.

Cultural barriers and process fossilization

• Barrier: Organizational culture and structure significantly impact the success of IT modernization initiatives. The technology is relatively easy when compared with shifting the habits and relationships among staff. Siloed departments, lack of collaboration, and resistance to change are common cultural barriers. As are outdated or inefficient processes being shoehorned into the modernized environment, because of a “this is how we do business here,” mentality. This leads to an old consulting joke. Q: What do you get when you add new technology to bad processes? A: Expensive, bad processes.
• Solution: Modernization is not simply updating technology; to be successful, it must change work habits and structures. Promote a culture of collaboration and innovation by breaking down silos and encouraging cross-functional teams. Also, reexamine current practices and processes. For example, Microsoft restructured its organization to foster a more collaborative environment, which was crucial for its successful transition to a cloud-first strategy. Establishing clear governance structures to oversee modernization efforts ensured alignment with business objectives. Leadership played a crucial role in driving cultural change, with executives championing modernization initiatives and leading by example.

Conclusion

IT modernization is complex but, if done mindfully and addressing the key barriers — legacy systems, budget constraints, skill gaps, security concerns, integration challenges, and cultural resistance and process fossilization — organizations can pave the way for a successful transformation.

Learn more about IDC’s research for technology leaders OR subscribe today to receive industry-leading research directly to your inbox.

International Data Corporation (IDC) is the premier global provider of market intelligence, advisory services, and events for the technology markets. IDC is a wholly owned subsidiary of International Data Group (IDG Inc.), the world’s leading tech media, data, and marketing services company. Recently voted Analyst Firm of the Year for the third consecutive time, IDC’s Technology Leader Solutions provide you with expert guidance backed by our industry-leading research and advisory services, robust leadership and development programs, and best-in-class benchmarking and sourcing intelligence data from the industry’s most experienced advisors. Contact us today to learn more.

Daniel Saroff is group vice president of consulting and research at IDC, where he is a senior practitioner in the end-user consulting practice. This practice provides support to boards, business leaders, and technology executives in their efforts to architect, benchmark, and optimize their organization’s information technology. IDC’s end-user consulting practice utilizes IDC’s extensive international IT data library, robust research base, and tailored consulting solutions to deliver unique business value through IT acceleration, performance management, cost optimization, and contextualized benchmarking capabilities.